Luddenden last night 28082022

Another Vine's Rustic here plus this beauty below which I can't make my mind up about, is it a Crescent or Ear Moth spp? I've seen a lot of Ear Moths including 17 here but they have never looked like this, a large moth at 17mm. Any ideas, I've still got it if anyone wants to see it

also a good autumn for Blood-vein (none in spring) but seven in the last two weeks

Vine's Rustic

Ear Moth?

Neglected Rustic - red form 23082022